“Don’t tolerate me as different. Accept me as part of the spectrum of normalcy.”
- Ann Northrop
“Don’t tolerate me as different. Accept me as part of the spectrum of normalcy.”
- Ann Northrop
“Freedom of Expression,”
A right said to be inherent
in all
But is it really?
That inherent right,
Isn’t it often curtailed
By the social constructions of gender?
Am I so wrong for feeling
suffocated
For not being able to be
who I am?
The pain pulsing in my heart,
Waiting to spew out
To dirty that “society”
with its
Ugly and slimy arms
Is it really dirty?
Is it that ugly?
To be who I am
To love who I want
To wear what I want
To walk my way
The way my legs & hips
take me
Is it really that ugly?
“Freedom of Expression,”
A right often said to
be inherent
But is it really?
That inherent right,
When am I to feel it
Removing those chains,
Shoving my words back in
my throat.
Those words brimming and
brimming,
Waiting to overflow
And let everyone know my
“ugly” secret,
Is trembling like a thin
leaf
As if it’s ready to fall
off
And leave the way it came
from,
Silently…
Silence, dark as it is,
Surrounds me.
Loud as it is,
Makes me lonely,
Begging for some warmth,
Waking that pulsating pain,
Showering me in salty, salty
tears,
Silently…
In the name of “Freedom
of Expression.”
Expression…Isn’t it to be
colourful and vibrant
So vibrant that it looks
Ugly but runs deep and beautiful,
Coming in different shapes
and sizes
To embrace all and all
Even in those salty, salty
tears,
Sharing vulnerabilities
And calling for inclusion
in its warmth?
That “Freedom of
Expression,”
Inherent in all,
Is it equal for “all”?
Is chains for some and freedom
for others
What equality means?
What “Freedom of
Expression” means?
I have grown up
From that time when I thought
Those labels that brought me near-salvation
Were everything.
Enlightened now, I see how futile
those were,
Those labels that do not exclusively
incorporate me,
Weren’t everything
Even in a world,
Of labels and categories
Of eagle-eyed looks,
Staring eagerly like hawks
To make a show of my confession
Of who I really am.
My confession makes those eagle-eyes
Turn inwards with the question,
“What all do I have to see,
To hear in this lifetime of mine?”
As if me, my labels, categorizations…
Are all burdens,
While I am actually
Opening my hands in invitation
To share their own blood and tears
With the promise of INCLUSION.
My, now, longer legs and bigger eyes
Take in the beauty in Sharing Vulnerabilities,
Those vibrantly coloured vulnerabilities,
With the lessons of blood and tears,
I realize that discrimination and marginalization
Is not a game like Olympics
Has never been one
To be won by the either team.
Lending a hand to those different,
Dripping the same blood as me,
Crying the same tears as me,
Doesn’t make my pain any lesser.
Rather I gain a warm hand
Enclosing mine,
Supporting mine,
Growing into a much warmer hug
And a promise of INCLUSION
Through Shared Vulnerabilities.
My little eyes keep drifting,
Tracing my mom’s shoulders,
Her curves which bore me,
Wondering if it’s okay to touch her
Wondering if it’s okay to ask for
help
Wondering if I would be hated for it
Wondering… Wondering and Wondering
While cold creeps through me,
I beg voicelessly,
“Please give me some warmth.
I’m so sorry for hurting you
Even if it was unintentional.
Please give me some warmth.”
Is it really cold?
Or is it loneliness?
But I can see the love in her eyes
Then, why is it so cold?
Why is it so lonely?
"Please hug me
Is it even okay for me to hug you?"
I wonder, wonder and wonder,
While I slowly rise
To meet my mom’s eyes.
Though taller than her,
The kid in me keeps
Tracing my mom’s shoulders,
Her curves which bore me…. As always
But now…
My longer legs slowly
Close the distance between us,
Tracing the smile glinting in her
eyes,
Pulling up the edge of her lips.
I fall into her arms,
Still wondering, wondering and
wondering.
While warmth creeps into
The cold barren me,
I realize,
“Wow! Mom is so warm.
Human warmth feels so good.”
Though words clog in my throat,
Atleast… Atleast,
It’s not as lonely,
It feels like home,
As if it’s a shame
To already loosen my arms embracing her.
I… I…
The kid in me
Already misses her arms around me.
Wondering… Wondering and Wondering
While cold creeps through me,
I beg voicelessly,
“Please give me some warmth.
I’m so sorry for hurting you
Even if it was unintentional.
Please give me some warmth, someone.”
I… I…
It was me, not the kid.
I miss her warmth,
That I got so little of.
Longing clouding my eyes,
I whisper,
“I love you.
I miss you.”
Wondering… Wondering and Wondering
While cold creeps through me,
I beg,
“Please give me some warmth.”
Recently, I came across the first
openly gay man to get awarded an Oscar, Mr. Dustin Lance Black. He was awarded
the Oscar for the screenplay of a movie called ‘Milk’. This 2008 movie
was written based on the life story of the first openly gay politician and
activist in America, Harvey Milk. It features the difficulties faced by Mr.
Milk in the 70s to become California’s first openly gay individual to get
elected to public office in a society where homosexuality was prosecuted and
his activities aimed at obtaining gay rights till he was assassinated.
Though it may not be embellished by high-investment-graphics
like the Marvel movies, it had beautifully portrayed the raw feelings of people
during the time and how the LGBTQ+ movements today are so similar to those
earlier but how they could be far more effective. Lance expertly describes how Harvey’s
ideology of bringing together different vulnerable groups and using the power
of one to help another helped Milk win the campaign against the repealing of
Proposition 6 with the aid of the worker groups. Moreover, Harvey also spreads
the heartfelt message of how hope will never be silent, which in itself
empowered me as a cisgender female LGBTQ+ individual.
Though almost the whole film continuously
gave me goosebumps with its powerful messages, Lance’s promise of getting the
court to repeal Proposition 8 while he was receiving his Oscar was the most overwhelming
and empowering message. The sheer fact that people of power and those having
celebrity status would take years off their career for the cause of letting
people live and express themselves as who they are and love who they want to was
very heartwarming. Furthermore, throughout their activities in regard to
Proposition 6 and Proposition 8, both Harvey and Lance, respectively, highlighted
the importance of personal stories rather than just blind marches and
processions to touch the hearts of fellow human beings.
Both Lance and Harvey has motivated me to use the story of my pain and hardships to slowly influence the people near me and then expand that influence to wider circles providing relief and helping many people of the heterosexual majority to understand and relate with the LGBTQ+ community. This has helped me understand that though it may take time, I have the power to sway a lot of people and do my hand to dispose off the prejudice related to the LGBTQ+ community, so that I can help both others and myself. I could see that from the sheer fact of how my mother, at first, was in denial when I came out but now accepts who I am and over time, she is understanding me more deeply. Thus, Milk (2008) has been the most relatable movie I have ever seen and it has been my favourite since then.
Poem
So
fleeting
The
moments that happened so fleetingly,
The
moments that I thought would last forever,
Shimmered
into oblivion within seconds.
Those
precious moments,
Forgotten
within the blink of an eye
Even
then I couldn’t do anything
And
when you broke down beside me,
Tears
adorned our eyes like crystals
Glinting,
as if waiting to erase our memories into oblivion.
Even
as we drift apart
I
can feel your eyes getting wet.
Over
time, those eyes
Those
beautiful eyes still pull me into you.
Both
of us wonder,
“Why
was it us?”
While
I trace your love,
Desperately
chasing my eyes
Looking
to comfort you
But
I couldn’t see that face of yours,
Looking
happy anymore
With
me just listening to you.
The
us, so similar but so different.
Slowly,
you begin to ignore my stares
Even
though I am waiting beside you
Missing
and longing for your hand in mine
Tears
adorn my eyes like crystals.
Even
as we drift apart
I
can feel your eyes getting wet.
Over
time, those eyes
That
pull me in
Were
the first.
Like
a kid who feels anxious
That
he would finish his candy and none would be left,
I
was afraid of the moment everything would go awry.
Though
you ran leaps to me while I took baby steps,
You,
now, turn your back towards me
And
I miss you so bad.
Even
though we peeled away the masks,
Hiding
the mysterious truths in us,
Understanding
each other hand in hand,
Nervous
as we were,
You
still keep your back turned
Without
even the glint of a smile.
It
was the first.
The
pandemic has made self-learning modules a necessity, if people are to get
educated. And it’s undeniable that the “basic necessities club” has a new
member now, i.e., the internet. So will this internet be able to replace a real
teacher? Well, as much as the collaboration of self-learning modules and
internet helps us educate the most remote areas of the world, self-learning
modules can’t play “substitute” for interpersonal relationships since they deliver
learning content in the form of discrete ‘atoms’, in the words of educator
Philip Kerr, which eventually come together to create ‘learning’. Using a more familiar
example, we may be able to engineer a zygote in a test tube in a lab but we
still need a human female to perform surrogate. Likewise, as much as all of us
can agree that education is a necessity to replace empty minds with open ones
and that it is wise to use all methods possible to fulfil the purpose even if
it entails not having a real teacher, we can’t deny the fact that the life experiences
and knowledge a real teacher brings is irreplaceable.
This
brings us to the reality that teaching is not all about itemizing facts and
figures of a certain topic. Attesting to this, research has shown that teaching
is not all about finding the “right answers” or teaching them to the students.
Rather, it is about inquiry and learning through which both the students and
the teachers ameliorate into better individuals, thus fostering social learning.
Therefore, the holistic development of a student requires more than just the
banter of teaching. It requires solid mentorship enriched by the happiness,
pain and sufferings of learned and experienced individuals dedicated to the
deed. Moreover, it can’t be denied that, often, we learn and model a
personalities and outlooks and alignment with the people around us, be it our
teachers, parents, friends or acquaintances. Additionally, though self-learning
modules lack prejudice, bias and stereotypes, it’s not like one can share their
thoughts and concerns with it and expect genuine understanding in return. This
in itself indicates that real people have a strong influence on the building of
the foundation of an individual.
Building
the foundation of an individual does not exactly end with enriching ones intellectual
quotient. This can be illustrated by the mere fact that an intelligent person
may turn murderer due to the lack of emotional intelligence while the opposite
is seldom true. This is where the role of a real teacher comes in. A teacher has
the ‘real-time’ sensitivity to understand the emotional state of each individual
student and offer an ear to listen or a shoulder to lean on, providing comfort
and proper guidance. This entails breaking down the barriers of employing the
conventional quantitative methods and epistemologies embedded in the academic
culture operating from an outsider’s perspective and making informed decisions
in regard to the student. In alignment with this argument, a teacher often uses
qualitative knowledge seen through an insider’s lens through methods like journaling,
direct observation, keeping field notes, conducting interviews, collecting
artifacts, etc. which are more appropriate for the complex process of teaching
and learning as it is not practically possible for a self-learning module lacking
empathy.
2
out of 3 students say that their teachers are their role models. But have you
ever heard someone say the same about a self-learning module? Probably, not.
So, why is that? Well, the answer is rather simple. It’s because guiding
students to become proper human beings and inspiring them to excel in their
life by setting goals and achieving them are not exactly the forte of a self-learning
module. Attesting to this, We Are Teachers, an online media brand for educators,
have found that almost 79 percent of students say that their teachers
encouraged them to follow their dreams. Furthermore, feedback can touch the
heart of a fellow human being only when it is customized for each person and
has the warmth of goodwill. Such personal and warm feedback can help encourage
independence and increase confidence as confirmed by more than 80 percent of
the students who took part in the research conducted by We Are Teachers.
Confidence
stems from compassion. A compassionate teacher positively influences their
student even if things may seem grim for them. This is evidently different from
the mere graphics found at the end of a self-learning module congratulating a
student on successfully completing their studies. Graphical appreciation,
though boosts confidence, isn’t as effective as verbal and expressive
appreciation from teachers which stimulates the student’s brain much more than
the former by unshackling the student from toxic emotions. Thus, teachers
become a support system for their students forming a bond between them founded
on trust and affection which cannot be formed by a self-learning module. But this
doesn’t mean that technology should be taken away from the lives of the students.
It means that teachers need to make use of technology as an efficient assistant
while incorporating their humour, soft-skills coaching and behavioral
assessments and make memories which are sure to adorn their students’ faces
with a smile. Such gifts of happiness can only be presented by a real teacher.
If we really ponder over it, it’s clearly a given that no historical narrative can be said to be truly complete. But why? The answer is simple. History is written by the victorious or at least in favor of them and their aspirations are considered representative of the greater stratified India. These dominant narratives take precedence over the lesser or marginalized ones. But ironically, these marginalized ones are often far more in number than the, so called, “great leaders.” Therefore, there’s a need for a more comprehensive version of history opening a window to the trivials of the independence struggle. This is especially important in today’s times considering how people’s voices are gaining greater attention.
This is not to say that people’s voices have never been
given “the attention.” It’s just that it has never been enough. Even then, the
efforts of subaltern historians cannot be ignored. These 1970 historians like
Ranajit Guha, Sumit Sarkar and many others aimed to bring out the often
subsumed perspective of historical narratives sidelined by the hagiographic retellings.
They made history more intersectional and brought out the tales of smaller regional
struggles, which had different interests and objectives from that of the “great
leaders,” within the ambit of the independence struggle.
Now, when we say, “smaller regional struggles,” this is
another massive category to cover. But the major part and the most ignored of
them were:
Women, their issues, participation, the stakes they had, etc.,
haven’t been given enough attention in the hagiographic version of Independence
struggle. Even if they are heard, the count is limited to a few prominent ones
like Sarojini Naidu, Aruna Asif Ali, Bhikaiji Cama, etc. But there are other
seemingly ordinary household names buried in the hearts of a few who share the
memories of the pain and suffering of those multiple and marginalized women.
One such example is Matangini Hazra, popularly known as Gandhi
Buri. She participated in both the Quit India Movement and the Non-Cooperation
Movement and showcased her chivalry by leading a procession, holding an Indian
flag and shouting ‘Vande Mataram,’ even after being shot thrice. Her statue has
also been put up in Kolkata at the spot where she was killed in Tamluk and the
Hazra road in Kolkata has also been named so in her honour.
Another woman is Kanaklatha Barua, popularly known as Birbala.
She led the female volunteers in the Quit India Movement in 1942 at Barangabari.
At the young age of 18, she was shot dead by the British police for her noble
efforts to hoist the national flag at the British dominated Gohpur Police
Station by shouting the slogans “British imperialists should go back” etc.
Other than these few examples, there were many more sacrifices
made attesting to the involvement of women in the Indian freedom struggle.
Peasant issues are dominated by grievances due to unfair land
ownership and tenancy in British India. One such movement is the Pabna Movement
of the 19th century. This riot, though supported by big names of the
time like Bankim Chandra Chatterjee, Indian Association under Surendranath
Banerjee, etc., was led mainly by the peasants toiling due to the exorbitant
rents and taxes and the Occupancy Right under Act X of 1859. In opposition to
these unjust policies, in May 1873, the peasants came together to form an
Agrarian League in the Yusufshahi Pargana of Pabna district, Patna, East
Bengal. The struggle, focusing less on violence and more on legal resistance, continued
till 1885 when the Government enhanced the occupancy rights of the peasants by implementing
the Bengal Tenancy Act of 1885.
Another movement was in the Jalpaiguri region of Bengal against
the jotedari system which forced the landless peasants to pay exorbitant rents
reducing them to conditions worse than that of the serfs.
Tribal struggles are a lot similar to the peasant grievances
as they were forced into bonded labour under the British Raj. One such struggle
was the Santhal bataidar agitation in Bihar that continued even after
independence. They rose against the landed elite or the maliks, to whom they
were bound. Anand Chakravarti, author of Social Power and Everyday Class
Relations: Agrarian Transformation in North Bihar (2001), opines that the
reason for this uprising was that the freedom movement and the Congress failed
to account for their interests. Likewise, it can be noted that the interests of
many other groups may have been ignored in the rat race towards popular
interests.
There were a number of movements in the pre-independent
India even before the incidence of trade unions. Some of the less eye-catching
ones were that of the plantation and mine workers who were heavily exploited by
the plantation and mine owners and mangers. In contrast, the cotton and jute
workers were more in the limelight receiving support from philanthropists.
Following these developments, Bombay emerged as a major city and gained importance. In this scenario, the Bombay dock workers rose up revolting against the British for their labour rights and formed the Bombay Dock Workers’ Union in 1932, at a time when forming trade unions was considered a criminal act. This was a turning point in the Indian freedom struggle showing the national leaders the importance of integrating the multiple and marginalized local movements to the “greater struggle.”
Soon, most nationalist meetings
started to take place in working class neighborhoods out of the realization that
the dock workers had the potential to disrupt trade and thus, adversely impact
the colonial administration. This was made true by persuading the dock workers
to adopt a hands-off attitude towards foreign cargo, consequently disrupting
foreign trade.
The aforementioned individuals and organizations constitute
just the tip of the iceberg. Many more women, peasants, tribals, workers and others have
been buried in the leaflets of history without due recognition. These endeavors,
however negligible they may seem, need to be recognized so as to provide a much
more enlightening and educated perspective of the Independence struggle to the
posterity and give enough credit to those who rightly deserve it.